Skip to content →

iOS 26 is shaping up to be a usability nightmare

Apple’s new design language for iOS, called Liquid Glass, makes controls and other surfaces translucent. In addition to the translucency, there are animated distortion and lighting effects on these elements. Combined, these reduce overall usability, for no reason other than fashion. There are no features in this new OS where Liquid Glass improves usability, and countless regressions that will make iPhones harder to use.

Photo stolen from the web. Hand holding iPhone.

iPhone OS 26 beta with translucent controls. The Control Center panel is pulled down over the home screen. Home screen colors all bleed through the panel and many of its buttons sit directly on top of home screen buttons. This gives some of the control panel buttons, which are otherwise mostly colorless, bright coloring.

The foundation of Liquid Glass is translucency: things from the background show through to the foreground. Translucent buttons and other controls over arbitrary and changing content means the controls themselves become arbitrary and changing, and that’s just bad for usability. UI elements changing appearance because the content underneath has changed not only makes controls less recognizable, it often directly impairs readability.

With iOS 26, a translucent button might be tinted red with one wallpaper and green with another. Text might appear white against a white background, or black on black. Button borders can vanish depending on what’s underneath. Simply adding a new app to your home screen could change the coloring of all the controls on a sheet that opens above it. The Music App’s toolbar might be visible on top of one album cover but not another.

This is terrible for usability and accessibility.

Before I go further, understand this: accessibility is usability. Usability means usable by everyone, those who think of themselves as disabled, and those who don’t.

Consider contrast and its role in readability. White text on a white background is unreadable to everyone, right? But what about light gray text on a white background? It turns out we can measure these things and follow widely accepted guidelines to ensure legibility.

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, the most authoritative standard for software, call for a color contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 for text legibility. Contrast ratio measures the difference in perceived brightness (luminance) between text and its background. A ratio of 1:1 means no contrast at all (e.g., white on white) and 21:1 is maximal contrast (e.g., black on white). The 4.5:1 minimum ensures most people can read the text. The further below that threshold, the more people are excluded.

Liquid Glass means buttons, controls, and text now have variable contrast ratios. White text within a translucent dialog might be very legible over a dark background. But on a light background, it could be harder to read, or even completely unreadable. Buttons suffer too. A button with little contrast against its background makes the tap target unclear. A highly contrasting border might help that button, but Liquid Glass uses translucent borders too, which can’t be relied on either.

Text, buttons, and controls in iOS 26 will literally disable millions, perhaps hundreds of millions, of users. Many people who could effectively use earlier versions of iOS will now have to dive into the “Accessibility” settings just to restore basic usability, or find another smartphone altogether. And this will affect some groups more than others. Older adults, for example, will struggle more than younger users. That’s because aging eyes experience thickening and yellowing of the lens, reducing light and contrast sensitivity.

And it’s not just a vision issue. People with memory challenges or other cognitive disabilities might struggle to find a button that was red yesterday and green today. Others may be distracted, overstimulated, or disoriented by the background “noise” bleeding through, and the animated reflections may worsen things, especially for people with motion sensitivities.

Apple has spent decades patting itself on the back for the accessibility of its software. Its quarterly shareholder reports routinely highlight its commitment to making inclusive products. And that praise was justified for many years. As an accessibility professional, I’ve long held Apple up as an example. Apple has done a good job on accessibility and it couldn’t have done so without teams of skilled usability and accessibility experts who had the power to insist on meeting basic standards.

That no longer seems to be the case.

The talent has left, or more likely, leadership has dis-empowered them, because this isn’t good design. It’s fashion over function, the opposite of what good design is supposed to be.

Published in Uncategorized

Comments are closed.