In an earlier post I wrote
Both [Apple and Meta] are pursuing AR (augmented reality) spectacles and also pushing the false narrative that spectacles are the natural evolution of goggles, that goggles weren’t an outrageously expensive mistake and would evolve to something better, as almost all of our tech gets smaller and better over time.
The second lie instigated by these companies and now percolating around the online VR fan base, particularly Apple users who paid about $4K for their goggles, is that hardware prices necessarily come down over time, that a second version will be more affordable than the first, and the third version even more so because “that’s just how technology works, it gets smaller and cheaper with each new version.”
But device prices are based heavily on hardware costs and those costs usually only come down with scale. There are cost savings as the cutting edge components, last year’s flagship chips for example, migrate to the mid-range a year or two later, and not long after that are incorporated into budget models. But that only happens when the scale of the flagship component is large and the demand for more budget friendly options is high. For laptops and smartphones, which have massive scale, components come down in cost rather quickly and this means that last year’s top of the line parts can be resold in this year’s mid-range products at more affordable prices.
Unfortunately for VR fans, goggles rely on low-volume cutting edge technologies and those components, like the micro-OLED displays in the Vision Pro or the bespoke lenses in the Quest 3, are all goggle-specific, where volumes are low and new generations are slow to arrive.
Those outrageously expensive Vision Pro displays, made by one company in extremely low volume, aren’t going to magically become less expensive this year compared to last, and that’s the case with most of the components in VR goggles. Costs don’t fall dramatically for short run custom parts and so prices won’t fall without headset vendors taking a haircut.
If Apple is going to bring down prices for its head mounted computers, it’s going to have to ramp production dramatically or lower the quality. Meta recognized a year or two ago, when sales of its Quest headset began to stall out at numbers that would embarrass the last place console maker, that scale wasn’t going to happen, so it built a budget model with cheaper components, worse visual fidelity and ergonomics, shaving about 20% off of the cost and price (Meta sells Quest at near cost while Apple sells Vision Pro at about a 250% markup.) Unfortunately, the budget model hasn’t sold very well, doing little or nothing to reverse the slide in Quest usage.
VR hardware companies are in a bind. The technology is expensive and demand is tepid. Without increased demand, or some technological breakthrough that’s unlikely to materialize, they can’t get the scale to bring their costs down which means high prices for consumers which further curbs demand.
So, what can they do? My advice would be to put all they can into finding the software killer app, the use case that will make these expensive products useful to a much larger audience. Meta pinned those hopes on gaming; Quest is a game console for your face. But a niche within a niche isn’t scale. I think Apple saw Meta struggling to break into the mainstream with a gaming device and so positioned Vision Pro as a productivity device. Unfortunately for Apple, most people do their productivity stuff at work and no one wants to wear goggles at work.
We’re probably entering another VR winter while we wait on the next technology breakthrough or an entirely new use case emerges. Hopefully next time’s the charm.
Comments are closed.